[Full Text] Major Hair Salon Chain “Earth Group”: Franchise Owners Speak Out! “We’re Essentially Working for Free”

Headquarters manages bank accounts and seals; owners of unprofitable stores receive no salary
“In the beauty industry, material and labor costs are skyrocketing, and the business environment is getting tougher every year. Amid all this, we at Earth Group have an unbelievable rule: ‘We pay absolutely no salary to franchise (hereinafter ‘FC’) owners of stores operating at a loss,’” said Mr. A, an FC owner.
The “Earth Group,” a hair salon chain with 258 locations nationwide, is an industry leader that posted 21.3 billion yen in sales for fiscal year ’24. However, Mr. A and several other FC owners are reportedly outraged, stating, “We’re essentially working for free, and we’re being pushed to the brink mentally.”
The franchise system is one in which the headquarters provides the brand’s trademark and management know-how in exchange for franchisees paying a set royalty. In principle, under a franchise agreement, both parties are equal and independent business operators. However, at Earth Group, it is said that the headquarters handles everything from managing franchisee sales revenue to calculating the owners’ salaries.
“After working at Earth as an assistant and then serving as a store manager, I went into business for myself. I am currently a franchise owner at a store in the Tokyo metropolitan area. At our company, each store’s sales proceeds are first collected by headquarters and then disbursed to the stores as ‘salaries’ and ‘operating expenses.’Headquarters also manages the passbooks and seals for each store’s corporate bank accounts, so even though it’s our own money, we can’t access it freely. On top of that, headquarters takes about 5% of sales—and up to 20% when you include various other fees. We’re barely scraping by…” (Mr. A)
Still, things were fine as long as the “salary” was being paid, but suddenly, a new rule was established.
“I think it was about seven or eight years ago… At a meeting attended by franchisees from across the country, President Toshiharu Kokubu declared, ‘We will not pay salaries to franchisees of stores operating at a loss.’It wasn’t as if we signed a new contract; it was simply announced verbally without any explanation. Since then, while the payment statements show that salaries are being paid, owners of stores operating at a loss haven’t actually received any.”
Mr. B, a franchise owner who joined Earth in the Kanto region 10 years ago, also lamented, “I’m working without pay.”
“Until about 10 years ago, headquarters was consistently paying us a ‘salary.’ Even owners of stores operating at a loss received a ‘salary.’ So why did this suddenly change…? We franchise owners are worried that ‘headquarters might be in financial trouble,’ but President Kokubu hasn’t provided any explanation.”
How are the owners of unprofitable stores making ends meet?
“They’re taking on day-labor jobs or dipping into their savings. I’ve even heard that some owners, struggling to make ends meet, have resorted to taking money from the register,” said Mr. A.
Working nonstop is the right approach
According to Mr. C, a franchise owner in the Kanto region, “A decision was made this past August that felt like a final blow.”
“President Kokubu announced via the group LINE chat and over the phone that ‘we will not pay salaries to store owners whose stores have outstanding loans with headquarters.’ Running a store requires initial investment and daily operating capital.We franchise owners have entrusted our bank passbooks and personal seals to headquarters, and any loans from banks go through headquarters. In other words, headquarters knows exactly which stores have taken out loans. Borrowing a substantial amount of money from a bank to open a business is standard practice in any industry. Using that as a reason to ‘withhold salaries’ is outrageous.”
Even so, there is reportedly an atmosphere that makes it difficult to speak out. Mr. D, who is also a franchise owner, reveals the reason: “It’s because quite a few owners idolize President Kokubu.”
“They’re known as the ‘Earth Family,’ and they subscribe to the philosophy that ‘working without rest is the right way.’ Since President Kokubu succeeded by doing just that, he expects the same from franchise owners.”
The second photo is a screenshot from a LINE group chat where the owners participate. Accompanied by the text “What are you doing?”, it shows President Kokubu listing stores with low sales and reprimanding them.
Attorney Masanori Nakamura, an expert on franchise systems, sounds the alarm.
“If the company notified owners of stores operating at a loss that they would not be paid their commissions and then enforced that policy, it could constitute an abuse of a dominant position under the Antimonopoly Act. While it is said that headquarters centrally manages franchisees’ sales and determines commission amounts, unless there is a clear provision in the contract, the funds should be refunded to the franchisees within a reasonable timeframe.This may also constitute a violation of the obligation to deliver funds to the principal (the franchisee) by the agent (the headquarters) under Article 646 of the Civil Code regarding accounting agency services.”
Is it true that the headquarters unilaterally notified franchise owners of the non-payment of commissions? Why was it decided not to pay commissions to stores operating at a loss or with outstanding loans? How do you respond to Attorney Nakamura’s allegations? When we asked Earth Headquarters, we received the following response.
“There is absolutely no truth to the claim that we issued a blanket notice refusing to pay commissions to owners of stores operating at a loss or who have outstanding loans to headquarters.Based on the contracts between our company and each franchisee, we conduct proper accounting and settlement (including set-offs) in accordance with prior agreements and our terms and conditions. Regarding the liquidity issues (cash shortfalls) experienced by some franchisees, these are not attributable to our management system or any unjustified non-payment on our part.”
Mr. A vehemently countered Earth Headquarters’ outright denial of the allegations.
“It’s clear from my bank account that my compensation is zero in months when the company runs a deficit. What exactly do you mean by ‘processing in accordance with prior agreements and regulations’? I have no recollection of ever entering into such a contract or agreement.”
Mr. A and others have already consulted with the Fair Trade Commission. How will the government assess the current situation at Earth, a company that has long been a leader in the beauty industry?


From the November 13 & 20, 2026, combined issue of “FRIDAY”
PHOTO: Kazuhiko Nakamura (Store Exterior)