Why Do Only Humans Have “White Eyes”? A Zoologist Explains Why Dogs and Cats Don’t Have Them… The Surprising Survival Strategy

The White of the Eyes: An Evolution for “Cooperation”
A handwritten sign at a pet shop in Nagaoka City, Niigata Prefecture, has gone viral in an unprecedented way, drawing visitors from all over the country who say, “The animals are so cute.” The large black pupils in the center of the white eyes are adorable. However,
“Only humans have white eyes like this,”
says animal behaviorist Shiro Kojima, who has researched the morphology of primate eyes and pioneered the study of the whites of the eyes on a global scale.
Now that you mention it, neither dogs nor cats have white sclera like humans do.
“The white part of the eye is called the ‘sclera,’ which maintains the shape of the eyeball and protects the retina and lens inside the eye from external impacts and foreign objects. Monkeys also have a sclera, but they naturally darken the white sclera to make it harder to tell where they’re looking,” (Mr. Kojima; same below)
The reason they go to such lengths to hide their gaze is that, for wild animals, revealing where they are looking can be a matter of life and death. If their gaze is detected, their intended prey might escape; and when competing with others for food, for example, if it’s clear where they’re looking, there’s a risk that someone else might snatch the food away.
Yet the human sclera has evolved to be white. This is because,
“to enable cooperative hunting, cooperative child-rearing, and mutual cooperation among peers. By evolving a white sclera, humans dramatically increased the potential for eye-contact communication.”
The eyes speak as loudly as the mouth; there are many expressions used to describe eye communication, such as “shifty eyes” or “eyes that don’t smile.” For humans living in a cooperative society, keeping their gaze open was an advantage for survival.
In fact, according to a study that examined where people look on another person’s face, it was found that humans focus on the area around the eyes, while gorillas and orangutans look at the entire face, and chimpanzees look around the mouth. They are trying to glean information from the eyes to understand what the other person is thinking.

Why Dogs Stare at Their Owners’ Faces
Still, there are times when it seems like your dog is communicating with you through its eyes. Is this just your imagination?
“Wolves, the ancestors of dogs, don’t have whites of the eyes, but they have yellow irises and black pupils. This makes their gaze easy to read.Since they live in packs, wolves also communicate through eye contact. Dogs, as descendants of wolves, also read human eye contact. It’s believed that when they stare intently at their owner’s face, they’re trying to figure out where the human is looking and what they’re thinking. Other animals don’t do that.”

“Looking up with big eyes” is a universal weapon
There is another way in which human eyes differ from those of other animals: they are very horizontally elongated, with a large proportion of the eye consisting of the white sclera.
“When we analyzed monkeys by dividing them into arboreal and terrestrial groups, we found that arboreal monkeys have round eyes, while those that live on the ground have horizontally elongated eyes. This is likely because living on the ground increases the need for a wider horizontal field of vision. However, in the case of humans, our eyes are so horizontally elongated that this alone doesn’t fully explain it,”
As for why human eyes became so horizontally elongated, Mr. Kojima suggests that it may be related to a form of communication that utilizes horizontal eye movements. For example, when a woman casts a shy glance, she might look up from a diagonal angle below. Such behavioral patterns are said to be universal across the globe.
It can be said that humans make full use of the whites of their eyes to express emotions. As a result, their eyes have become much more horizontally elongated than those of other animals, and the proportion of the whites has increased significantly.
“Nowadays, many scholars are conducting research on the whites of the eyes, and it’s said that their role isn’t limited to communication alone. For example, they can indicate a person’s health, or the whiter the whites, the more attractive a person appears. However, communication is the most important function. I believe this to be undeniable.”
If the whites of our eyes became large and white so that we could work together and connect with one another, why do conflicts arise in so many places? Will people who attack others—those who go against the course of evolution—eventually be weeded out?
▼ Shiro Kojima: Animal behaviorist. Former Professor and Director of the Kyoto University Center for Wildlife Research; currently Professor Emeritus. Specializes in animal behavior, ecology, and snow and ice biology. In 1982, he traveled to the Himalayas, where he made the world’s first discovery of insects and water fleas (Hyogaso comi) living in glaciers, revealing that ecosystems exist even in the high-altitude regions of the Himalayas—above 5,000 meters—which had long been regarded as an inanimate world.He also conducted a comparative study of the external morphology of the eyes of approximately 88 primate species—representing nearly half of all extant primate species—and revealed that the human eye differs significantly from those of other primates not only in that a large portion of the sclera is exposed but also in its distinctly horizontal shape.

Reporting and Text: Izumi Nakagawa PHOTO: Afro (2nd photo)