Shabu-Ya or Yuzu-An… Four Experts Engage in a Heated Debate Over Which Shabu-Shabu Course Offers the “Best Value” and “Highest Satisfaction”

  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LINE
Exterior of Shabu Shabu On-Yasai

This shabu-shabu chain has gained popularity even amid rising prices because it lets diners enjoy generous portions of both meat and vegetables. The “Four Sages” of the dining world—food industry producer Mitsuhiko Suda, B-grade gourmet explorer Kyubei Yagyu, food journalist Junnosuke Nagahama, and food analyst Takao Shigemori—conduct a thorough comparison of the restaurant’s best-value set menus.

In Part 1, we examined “Shabu-Ya’s” lunch menus in the 1,000-yen range and its Japanese Black beef courses. In Part 2, we’ll expand our scope to include “Shabu-Shabu On-Yasai,” “Yuzu-an,” and “Washoku Sato,” and finally select one restaurant for “Best Value” and another for “Highest Satisfaction.”

Click here for Part 1

High Quality Beyond Just the Meat

Suda: “Shabu-Ya” is more like a family restaurant, while “On-Yasai” has more of an izakaya vibe. They also offer a wide selection of alcoholic beverages.

Nagahama: As the name suggests, their carefully selected domestic vegetables are their selling point, and they’ve really captured the female customer base.

Shigemori: On the other hand, perhaps out of pride as a long-established restaurant, their high-end set menus really stand out.

Nagahama: From that higher price range, I’d like to recommend the “Kuroge Wagyu Course” (5,478 yen). Since it includes all-you-can-eat Kuroge Wagyu and beef tongue, it offers great value for the price.

Shigemori: If you order the sukiyaki broth for the steamed vegetables, you’ll get an egg for free. It’s also a good idea to choose sukiyaki as one of your hot pot broth options.

Yagyu: I recommend either the “San’en Pork Course” (usually 3,718 yen / 3,278 yen for lunch), which is the lowest-priced all-you-can-eat option, or—from the non-all-you-can-eat menu—the “Kuroge Wagyu Shabu-shabu Set” (2,948 yen / 2,618 yen for lunch).The reason I chose the “Sangen Pork” is the high quality of the “All-You-Can-Eat Menu Common to All Courses”—which includes the warm vegetables and other items besides the meat.

The lineup is extensive, featuring items like “Salted Beef Tongue Salad” and “Chewy Water Dumplings.” To enjoy this all-you-can-eat selection, I keep the all-you-can-eat course at the lowest price. With the “Wagyu Set,” on the other hand, the focus is on savoring high-quality meat.To be honest, the portion sizes aren’t very generous, but being able to enjoy Kuroge Wagyu shabu-shabu for 2,618 yen is definitely appealing. I think a balanced approach—choosing between quantity and quality—is the best way to enjoy Onnayase.

Exterior of Yuzu-an

――Please tell us about “Yuzu-an” as well.

Yagyu: The fact that tempura is included in the all-you-can-eat menu is a major draw. Another feature is that the course options are simple, with just three tiers.

Shigemori: Only the cheapest “Basic Course” (3,278 yen) doesn’t include tempura. I think the “Seasonal Yuzu-an Course” (3,828 yen), which includes tempura, offers a better balance, so I recommend that one.

Nagahama: I agree. With the “Seasonal” course, you also get beef shabu-shabu, and the variety of sushi toppings increases. Including the tempura, it feels like a “Japanese cuisine festival,” and the value for money is outstanding.

Yagyu: Personally, I’d recommend going all out and choosing the top-tier “Luxury Course” (4,928 yen). It adds Kuroge Wagyu beef, and both the tempura and sushi are upgraded. For the tempura, you can choose between “giant shrimp tempura” and “nodoguro (blackthroat seaperch) tempura.”

The sushi selection also expands to include “Wild Bluefin Tuna Ootoro Temaki,” “Kuroge Wagyu Nigiri,” “Whole Snow Crab Nigiri,” and “Salmon Roe Gunkan,” among others. When you think about it, the sushi lineup is really impressive. It’s no wonder their brand logo reads “Sushi & Shabu-shabu Yuzu-an.”

Suda: I think the quality of the sushi is on par with major specialty chains like “Sushiro.” I’m definitely in the “luxury” camp myself. It just feels like such a real treat, and it’s amazing that a meal like this costs less than 5,000 yen.

Yuzu-an is operated by Monogatari Corporation, the same company behind “Yakiniku King.” Since they’re a company that prides itself on meat, the quality is high. I get the impression that the quality of their beef, in particular, is a step ahead of major chains.

Yagyu: If you’re looking for a bargain, Shabu-Ya will do just fine. But if you’re going to Yuzu-an, you might as well go all out and treat yourself.

Exterior of Sato Japanese Restaurant

What Is “Sato-Style Yakiniku”?

—Are there any other recommended set menus at other chains?

Yagyu: The “Beef & Pork Premium Course” (4,389 yen) from “Sato-style Yakiniku,” the all-you-can-eat course at “Washoku Sato ,” is quite unique. “Sato-style Yakiniku” uses an original teppan pot featuring a circular plate in the center and a hot pot around the edges. You can enjoy grilled meat on the plate and shabu-shabu in the hot pot.

A course that offers both all-you-can-eat shabu-shabu and yakiniku is rare in the industry. This course features a selection of both pork and beef for both the shabu-shabu and yakiniku sections. Sushi, tempura, yakitori, and gyoza are also all-you-can-eat. Considering how extensive the menu is, 4,389 yen is quite a bargain.The 120-minute time limit is also quite generous.

――Let’s move on to the conclusion. First, which “God-tier Value Course” offers the best value?

Suda: In terms of value, you should choose from Shabu-Ya’s weekday lunch options.

Shigemori: I agree. Among those, wouldn’t the “Pork Loin Shabu-shabu All-You-Can-Eat Course” be the best?

Nagahama: I’ll cast my vote for the “Pork Loin” as well. After all, an all-you-can-eat deal with no time limit for under 1,700 yen is truly impressive.

Yagyu: I’d like to recommend the “Beef & Pork Shabu-Shabu All-You-Can-Eat Course,” which also includes beef, but I have no objection to the “Pork Loin” being the best value.

――Next, which course offers the “Best Value for Satisfaction,” balancing price with customer satisfaction?

Shigemori: Here too, from Shabu-Ya, I’d recommend the “Kuroge Wagyu Shabu-Shabu All-You-Can-Eat Course” for weekday lunch. It retains the restaurant experience where you can serve yourself, while offering a wide selection of meats, including Kuroge Wagyu.

Nagahama: I was torn between On Yasai’s “Kuroge Wagyu Course” and Yuzu-an’s “Seasonal Yuzu-an Course,” but I’d love to eat as much beef shabu-shabu, sushi, and shrimp tempura as I want with the latter.

Suda: I also recommend Yuzu-an, but I’m casting my vote for the “Luxury Course.” It features high-quality Kuroge Wagyu and sushi that rivals that of specialty chains. The feeling of being treated to a feast is in a league of its own.

Yagyu: I also agree with the “Luxury Course.” Both the tempura and the signature dishes are so well-executed that it’s hard to choose just one. You can really feel the “joy of choosing”—one of the charms of all-you-can-eat dining.

After a heated debate, we decided that the “Best Value Course” is Shabu-Ya’s weekday lunch “Pork Loin Shabu-Shabu All-You-Can-Eat Course,” and the “Highest Satisfaction Course” is Yuzu-an’s “Luxury Course.” Why not use this discussion as a guide and enjoy some shabu-shabu to the fullest this fall, the season of hearty appetites?

The hot pot at Washoku Sato’s “Sato-style Yakiniku.” Enjoy grilled meat on the central plate and shabu-shabu in the surrounding pot.
No. 1 for Value
Shabu-Ya “Pork Loin Shabu-Shabu All-You-Can-Eat Course” (1,649 yen)
In this era of inflation, maintaining a price in the 1,000-yen range for an all-you-can-eat meal—including unlimited vegetables, desserts, and curry—offers incredible value
No. 1 in Satisfaction:
Yuzu-an “Luxury Course” (4,928 yen)
With a luxurious lineup featuring all-you-can-eat tempura, Japanese Black beef, and sushi—all priced under 5,000 yen—this course offers exceptional satisfaction

The prices listed for the featured menus are as of October 27 and are subject to change

From the November 13 & 20, 2026, combined issue of “FRIDAY”

Photo Gallery6 total

Related Articles