Japan’s Territory Disappearing? Alarming Loopholes You Can Exploit Without Any Contact—Beyond Government Control

A loophole that nationality reporting can’t prevent
Why Japan Can’t Ban Foreign Land Purchases Like China
Professor Kiyohito Adachi, who studies foreign land transactions from a legal perspective, is actually opposed to blanket restrictions on land acquisition by foreigners.
“In today’s globalized economy, overly restricting foreign land acquisition would harm Japan’s economy. Japanese citizens’ overseas real estate acquisitions could also be restricted, affecting economic activity. That’s why I don’t support a total ban.”
For example, China basically prohibits foreigners from purchasing and owning land. Yet Chinese capital is buying land in Japan.
“That doesn’t mean Japan can set restrictions against specific countries. Due to economic considerations, international rules, and other factors, it’s difficult to limit foreign real estate acquisitions in Japan.
However, I also believe there are problems in Japan’s real estate law itself.”
In Japan, land and buildings are treated as separate real estate, and numerous laws are complexly structured. Furthermore, different ministries oversee land/building registration, transactions, and use and planning. Professor Adachi points out that this vertical division is one of the problems of Japan’s real estate law.
“The Ministry of Justice is in charge of some laws, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism of others, and these laws aren’t well coordinated. For real estate law, the government and researchers should organically link laws across ministries.
On the other hand, I evaluate the 2020 revision of the Basic Land Act positively. It defines landowners’ responsibilities for proper use, management, and transactions of land and emphasizes considering regional characteristics. I think it’s possible to create a legal system that realizes this principle even within Japan’s current land law framework.”
The Nisekō situation relying on local governments?
While Professor Adachi opposes a complete restriction on foreign land acquisitions, he believes partial regulations should be implemented.
“For example, in Kutchan Town, Hokkaido, foreign investment and development have caused land prices to surge. The increase in foreign workers has pushed up rental property rates, making it harder for locals to secure housing. Foreign real estate investment is harming the well-being of local residents.
In Japan, under the principle of freedom in construction, buildings can be erected as long as they meet the Building Standards Act and City Planning Act. But land and buildings are the foundation of life, economy, and even survival and environment. Local governments should consider residents’ well-being and impose some regulations on their use.”
What kinds of regulations could local governments independently implement?
“Prefectures and municipalities can formulate urban plans under the City Planning Act. By designating urban planning areas or quasi-urban planning areas, various restrictions on land use and construction can be imposed.
However, some municipalities haven’t created urban plans. For example, Kutchan Town has urban planning areas and quasi-urban planning areas, and adjacent Niseko Town has quasi-urban planning areas, but surrounding municipalities have no designation. This could allow construction and development to proceed freely.
It might be worth considering creating broader urban plans covering entire regions.”
Last June, a Chinese company illegally cut about 3.9 hectares of forest in Hokkaido without permission, planning to build two houses. Construction was halted following a government order.
“Additionally, small-scale developments are occurring in Kutchan and Niseko, including abandoned plots where hotels were planned but never built. To prevent these mini-developments, stricter regulation under the City Planning Act is needed.
Introducing development taxes, villa taxes, or vacant house taxes could also help. Collecting demolition costs in advance as local taxes might also be effective.
For sustainable local communities, local governments must actively engage in policy creation.”
However, some argue that municipalities lack manpower.
“That may be true for small towns. But if the national government imposes blanket restrictions, municipalities can’t implement regulations suited to local circumstances. Specific land use regulations should be devised by each municipality.
For example, Kutchan and Niseko have landscape ordinances requiring developers to attend pre-development briefings for residents. Through these briefings, developers, administrations, and residents work together on community planning. This empowers both local governments and residents. Creating such mechanisms via town development and landscape ordinances is important.”
Foreign land acquisition and the resulting problems of ownerless land and mismanaged buildings cannot be solved by the government alone.
“Local governments and residents must gain strength and think about how to shape their communities and nation. Otherwise, Japan as a country cannot survive.
The national government should give more authority to municipalities. We citizens also need the insight to sift through overwhelming information and develop sound judgment.”
Kiyohito Adachi – Professor, Department of Economic Law, Faculty of Economics, Hokusei Gakuen University. Graduated Meiji Gakuin University, Faculty of Law, 1993; Waseda University Graduate School, Law, 2003. Specializes in civil law.
Interview and text by: Sayuri Saito PHOTO: Afro